How We Tested
We purchased eight different cartons of eggnog from a variety of grocery store chains.
They then selected an overall winner.
It was also ranked as the overall favorite by several editors.
Credit:Southern Living / Marina Meshcherskaia
Nice consistency and good spice, was how one editor described it.
Another said it was very creamy, not too sweet, and has a good spice level.
Ooh, I like the spice in this one, shared one editor.
Credit:Publix
It feels dimensional to me."
Very sweet, nearly boiled custard which is why I like it, shared one editor.
Its classic eggnog flavor without being overly sweet won over the testers.
Its the most well-rounded, said one editor.
Another described it as the closest to homemade.
